作者:吕开阳 & 本地AI

数据来源:PubMed(NCBI E-utilities在线检索,检索日期2026年11月12日)。八组检索式共命中11722条,按相关度题录采集1492条,经题录分类与摘要结构化提取,确定核心建模与临床预测建模类文献123条;正文按主题进行描述性综述,引用代表性文献95篇。

  全文 Word 文档:(约 59 KB,可直接下载)。

关键词:瘢痕;瘢痕疙瘩;增生性瘢痕;伤口愈合;数学模型;仿真建模;有限元法;反应-扩散;形态弹性;基于智能体模型;机械生物学;机器学习;数字孪生

1 引言

  皮肤创伤修复的最终结局是瘢痕形成。增生性瘢痕与瘢痕疙瘩是病理性瘢痕的主要类型,表现为胶原过度沉积、组织隆起、瘙痒疼痛及功能障碍,并造成显著的心理与美学负担。张力负荷、TGF-β信号、细胞外基质(ECM)重塑与机械转导被公认为病理性瘢痕形成的核心环节[1-3]。Cerda则从纯力学角度总结了瘢痕收缩、增厚及周围皮肤起皱等现象,指出瘢痕的局部化性质由皮肤背景张力决定,是皮肤张力场中的力学失稳产物[4]。

  数理模型与仿真建模为上述过程提供了定量化、机制化的研究工具。多篇综述指出,伤口愈合数学模型已由早期的表皮反应-扩散模型扩展到涵盖炎症、胶原沉积、组织力学与治疗干预的多尺度框架[5-8],复杂性科学视角亦主张将瘢痕视为自组织的复杂生物系统加以建模。本文对PubMed中瘢痕相关数理模型与仿真建模文献进行系统检索、分类与描述性综述,梳理其方法谱系、主要发现与转化趋势。

2 材料与方法

  数据源为PubMed,采用NCBI E-utilities在线检索(2026年11月12日)。设计八组检索式:M1 瘢痕/瘢痕形成/瘢痕疙瘩/增生性瘢痕与数学模型、计算模型、仿真、有限元、基于智能体、机械生物学、系统生物学、微分方程、动力学模型组合;M2 伤口愈合/关闭/修复/收缩与数学、计算、仿真、有限元及词题model组合,并限定瘢痕、成纤维细胞、胶原、肌成纤维细胞、角质形成细胞;M3 瘢痕疙瘩/增生性/病理性/异常瘢痕与model、仿真、有限元、机械生物学、生物力学、数学组合;M4 皮肤张力/力学/黏弹性/应力应变与瘢痕及建模组合;M5 瘢痕/瘢痕疙瘩/伤口愈合与激光、放疗、药物递送、曲安奈德、微针、缝合及建模仿真组合;M6 瘢痕与机器学习、人工智能、随机森林、神经网络、深度学习、预测模型、列线图组合;M7 morphoelastic(形态弹性)、wound closure model、皮肤/组织扩张、cell-based model、continuum model、hybrid model与瘢痕/伤口/皮肤/纤维化组合;M8 纤维化/纤维性/肌成纤维细胞与数学模型、计算模型、仿真、基于智能体、机械转导组合,并限定皮肤/伤口。各组按相关度排序采集前200条题录。

  筛选分两步。第一步题录分类,采用严格纳入标准:论文须提出、发展、应用或综述关于瘢痕、伤口愈合、瘢痕力学、瘢痕治疗或皮肤力学的数学/计算/仿真模型;排除动物、体外、临床“实验模型”,分子对接/药理计算,以及单纯力学测量研究。第二步对入选文献抓取摘要,逐条结构化提取发表年、期刊、模型类型、研究主题、方法与主要发现,并按主题归类形成描述性综述;时间分布与模型类型统计基于入选记录计算。

3 结果

3.1 检索与筛选结果

  M1-M8分别命中2666、3042、1650、502、417、319、2145、393条,去重后共采集1492条题录。题录分类得到核心建模类文献100条与临床预测建模类文献23条,共123条;548条为无计算建模的动物/体外/临床“实验模型”(如兔耳瘢痕模型、大鼠激光损伤模型等),797条为不相关文献(骨重建、空气污染、输尿管支架、传染病动力学、植物化学与分子对接等),其余为对接类噪声。123条入选文献全部完成摘要结构化提取,构成本综述的叙述基础。

3.2 时间分布与主题分布

  时间分布:最早的核心文献为1996年以TGF-β为刺激源的胶原纤维形成动力学模型[9];2000年前1条,2000-2009年9条,2010-2019年30条,2020-2022年23条,2023-2026年60条,近三年占入选文献近一半,呈明显加速趋势。期刊分布集中于Biomechanics and Modeling in Mechanobiology(7条)、Journal of Biomechanics(5条)、Acta Biomaterialia(4条)、Scientific Reports(4条)、Wound Repair and Regeneration(3条)、Burns(3条)、Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering(3条)、Journal of Mathematical Biology(3条)等。模型类型分布:有限元/连续介质力学20条,ODE/PDE与反应-扩散19条,建模综述20条,基于智能体9条,系统生物学/网络分析12条,治疗仿真4条,混合多尺度方法学1条,数字孪生1条,交叉与前沿方法(患者特异性仿真、高斯过程代理、物理信息神经网络、多模态成像、激光多物理场、力-仿生平台等)14条;临床预测模型(列线图、机器学习、深度学习)23条。

4 主题描述性综述

4.1 细胞动力学与反应-扩散/动力学模型

  此类模型以细胞与分子浓度场的时空演化为核心。1996年的胶原合成动力学模型以TGF-β各亚型分泌为刺激,数值求解胶原I:III比值对纤维直径的调控,同时再现胎儿无瘢痕修复与成人瘢痕化,确定了二者差异的关键参数(TGF-β亚型及其相对活性),提出局部应用特定TGF-β亚型可调节瘢痕化程度[9]。KGF介导的真皮-表皮信号反应-扩散模型以行波分析近似伤口闭合速率,发现伤后KGF大幅上调虽扩展信号范围却超出闭合速率最优值,提示其非促分裂原功能更为重要[10]。在糖尿病伤口中,将PDGF、成纤维细胞、胶原与透明质酸纳入巨噬细胞动力学模型,模拟Apligraf与Dermagraft治疗协议,提出伤口环境中透明质酸的增加是两类疗法起效的关键,愈合时间预测与临床试验观测相关[11]。VEGF-A mRNA空间分布的药代动力学与出芽血管PDE耦合模型预测:第0天在伤口边界注射优于后期注射,深入伤口1-2mm注射比边界注射更快愈合,限制扩散导致边界积累而延迟愈合[12]。加入MSC分化、外源机械应变及新本构关系的ODE模型首次直接预测愈合组织强度,宏观应变早期加速细胞响应并轻度提高胶原I:III比,预测强度与实验愈合真皮数据相符[13]。针对缺血性皮肤伤口,偏微分方程连续模型与基于智能体模型给出高度一致的伤口半径衰减曲线,并在缺血程度低于阈值时确认高压氧与持续局部氧疗可在约30天内实现完全闭合[14]。

  细胞个体建模方面,细胞Potts模型整合EGF-整合素表达-黏附的双相依赖,再现角质形成细胞在EGF梯度下的不对称迁移,解释了高EGF通过增强黏附减慢迁移导致再上皮化失败的机制[15]。表皮-真皮多尺度混合模型预测:表皮激活因子/抑制因子基线水平维持真皮稳态,其缺失导致隆起瘢痕样表型;伤口诱导表皮信号增加联合快速再上皮化可减小真皮瘢痕;高纤维蛋白凝块密度致增生性瘢痕、低密度致萎缩性瘢痕;浅表伤口整体瘢痕轻于深伤口[16]。在体单细胞激光损伤结合反应-扩散与分岔分析阐明ATP-P2Y受体介导的钙波径向传播跨越多个细胞层级,连接蛋白半通道参与远距离传播,而基底角质形成细胞因P2Y/PLC不足不能维持钙振荡[17];果蝇上皮激光伤口模型进一步量化钙事件,证明细胞间变异性与IP3细胞间传递对协调远离伤口的钙信号为必需[18]。力学-化学耦合PDE模型经线性稳定性分析表明拉伸条件下真皮可失稳产生与临床平行的条纹,合理解释膨胀纹的启动[19]。韧带修复反应-扩散模型再现肿胀、PDGF招募与未成熟胶原的随机取向[20]。uPA-纤溶酶原激活的ODE系统经相平面与分岔分析证实双稳态,开关样动力学与伤口愈合及纤维化相关[21]。珊瑚伤口愈合的4-ODE机制模型拟合线形与圆形伤口数据,被用于指导微片段化珊瑚礁修复[22]。

4.2 伤口收缩、胶原重塑与形态弹性模型

  伤口收缩与胶原重塑是瘢痕形成的组织学核心,形态弹性(morphoelasticity)框架在此最为活跃。2D混合模型将ECM建模为纤维增强各向异性软组织,其弹性属性随胶原密度与取向动态演化,成纤维细胞浸润并沉积胶原、纤维与迁移细胞及张力场动态对齐,支持核心假说:瘢痕是收缩张力场中胶原合成与定向排列的产物,伤口形态改变可改变收缩速率与瘢痕质量[23]。一维形态弹性模型耦合信号分子、成纤维细胞、肌成纤维细胞与胶原模拟烧伤后瘢痕挛缩,敏感性分析确定真皮平衡胶原浓度、细胞凋亡率与信号分泌率为最敏感参数,可模拟儿童因生长产生附加力而挛缩更强、老年挛缩较少等年龄差异[24];针对该框架的连续与半离散稳定性分析给出依赖信号衰减率的稳定性约束,证明截断误差为二阶量级,保障参数不产生非生理结果[25];二维扩展模型进一步完成连续PDE与半离散表示的稳定性分析[26],2D生物形态弹性模型的敏感性分析确定泊松比、胶原平衡浓度、收缩抑制常数与肌成纤维细胞凋亡率最敏感,并指出成纤维细胞与肌成纤维细胞增殖率不相等时模型适配显著改善[27]。

  耦合与多尺度方法方面,ABM-FEM耦合模型将成纤维细胞与肌成纤维细胞区分建模,Monte Carlo敏感性分析显示第4天伤口面积与最终最小面积高度相关,可据早期数据预测患者伤口演变,最终达到5%收缩的概率约为0.627[28]。基于个体的平滑粒子方法与连续介质模型之间建立严格upsampling关系,1维给出闭式解,多维经数值验证,为收缩问题的尺度链接提供统一框架[29]。在Bell黏附动力学基础上引入纤维蛋白与胶原非线性力学的多尺度模型,将微观黏附嵌入有限元组织力学平衡,在每个积分点双向耦合,再现生物聚合物纤维力学响应、成纤维细胞收缩应力与创面应力-应变曲线[30]。非线性大变形有限元模拟手术伤口,首次系统处理伤口深度:同等面积下较深伤口收缩更少、更早达到最大收缩速率[31]。基于图像的多尺度模型预测成纤维细胞-纤维蛋白凝胶24小时区域重塑,定性再现固定与自由边界条件下的差异,但凝胶变形量与速率与实验不符,暴露参数化短板[32]。ABM与FEM跨尺度耦合方法学研究揭示:ABM网格细化在细胞拥挤出现时产生意外的增殖/迁移变化,FEM网格细化放大相邻单元应变差异,应变依赖的胶原转化反馈放大区域异质性,建议网格密度选择须由实验数据指导[33]。PhysiCell平台的中细节ECM框架以各向异性、密度、纤维总取向三个变量表征微结构,双向耦合细胞行为,在伤口愈合、集体迁移等场景验证并开源[34]。

4.3 皮肤本构、缝合与皮瓣力学及减张仿真

  皮肤力学建模的基础是可靠的本构模型。基于长链分子统计力学的皮肤胶原网络各向同性非线性弹性本构模型复现体内外应力-应变,预测增生性瘢痕的胶原网络密度更高、纤维自由长度更短[35];对健康人与瘢痕皮肤的二轴试验结合二次谐波生成显微成像与三维纤维取向分布量化,完整标定纤维增强超弹性本构参数,识别参数间相关性,为含瘢痕皮肤的仿真提供标定基础[36]。在应用层面,有限元求解正各向异性皮肤对梭形、椭圆形、三角形伤口缝合的主应力与位移,以最小主应力定义最优缝合模式,高应力区与愈合缓慢及瘢痕形成相关[37]。皮肤皮瓣的有限元力学分析首次显示模拟最大应力区域与临床组织坏死区域直接相关[38];进一步量化松弛皮肤张力线方向的影响:皮瓣垂直于张力线推进时应力最小,推进皮瓣最大应力位于远端,back-cut设计增加侧缘应力,术前优化可望减少裂开与增生性瘢痕[39]。有限应变不可压缩超弹性膜模型自动模拟Z成形术、多重Z成形术与菱形皮瓣的转位与皱褶形成,识别减少术后瘢痕的最优转位方案[40];W成形术2D平面应力模型显示三角瓣内应力显著低于缝线周围,最大压缩应力对应狗耳朵区域,其有效性归因于几何设计本身[41];表皮-真皮-皮下三层正交各向异性超弹性有限元图谱系统刻画伤口几何与一期缝合的应力传播,提供开源可复现代码并明确走向临床的假设障碍[42]。

  减张与张力管理是力学模型直接指导临床的代表方向。力调节组织桥(FMTB)的非线性大变形有限元模型联合猪与人体点阵网格应变验证显示:组织-缝合线界面压应力约4000 mmHg,组织-FMTB界面仅约20 mmHg,10天治疗期内维持约30%的张力降低[43]。3D打印透明面罩压力治疗的有限元模型与实验压力测量显著相关(P<0.05),薄软组织与骨性突起区承受集中压力、厚软组织区压力不足,为面罩设计优化提供依据[44]。基于约束混合物理论的剖腹正中切口缝合后6个月愈合FE模拟表明,缝线降解后伤口组织的弹性应变是切口疝发展的主要风险因素,咳嗽等间歇腹压升高影响愈合,研究明确支持建立伤口愈合数字孪生的前景[45]。乳房-假体缝合皮瓣模型计算缝合张力达0.025 N、乳晕周围Cauchy等效应力峰值380 kPa,圆形假体瘢痕应力比解剖型高13.4%,提示圆形假体使瘢痕承受更高负荷[46];保乳术后空腔愈合的生化-力学多尺度模型用人临床与猪组织病理数据校准,评估空腔/乳房体积比与组成对收缩及美容结局的影响[47]。腹腔镜穿刺孔FE模拟显示侧位穿刺孔变形强烈依赖其刚度,建议侧位穿刺孔缝合甚至假体加固以预防穿刺孔疝[48]。对椭球状痤疮瘢痕疙瘩的FEA显示,随长轴增大,牵张应力由核心集中转为均匀,最终聚焦于受牵拉的瘢痕边缘浅层真皮,解释“蟹钳样”生长,结合220例临床测量提出直径4-5 mm即应干预[49]。

  计算加速是近年的显著趋势。高斯过程代理模型在有限元结果上训练,可预测推进、旋转、转位皮瓣在任意材料参数下的应力应变并做全局敏感性分析与优化,计算效率远高于直接FE模拟[50];贝叶斯神经网络复现形态弹性有限元的一年期烧伤后皮肤收缩演化,平均R²=0.9928,较直接FE计算提速19354倍[51];高斯过程模型由表面波速反演皮肤应力与自然预拉伸,预测性能R²=0.9570,经合成皮肤实验验证,为体内皮肤张力的非侵入测定及植皮收缩补偿提供工具[52]。

4.4 皮肤扩张与生长建模

  组织扩张是生长驱动皮肤力学的典型问题。轴对称皮肤扩张有限元模型经体外验证,与力学刺激驱动的生长律耦合估算皮肤面积增益,提出扩张器设计与临床流程的预测工具[53]。连续介质生长框架将变形梯度乘性分解为弹性与生长部分,生长刻画为不可逆、拉伸驱动、横观各向同性过程,用单一标量生长乘子参数化,模拟组织扩张器逐步充气、放气后残余应力,比较四种扩张器几何的面生长与残余应力时空演化,提出标准化扩张器几何、尺寸、置入位置与充气时机的临床参数建议[54]。圆形扩张植入物在皮肤下扩张的首次数值研究定量给出随时间产生的额外皮肤量与扩张液体量的对应关系[55]。2D多层morphoelastic生长模型支持扩张中新网状脊形成源于生长组织力学二次屈曲的假说,对稳态拉伸、层厚与剪切模量稳健,新网状脊谷出现在原始波峰位置[56]。机器学习预测方面,在1000例虚拟受试者波传播数据集上训练人工神经网络,由非侵入测量预测体内皮肤生长,7天生长平均R²=0.9353,剪切模量R²=0.9801、生长率R²=0.8649、自然预拉伸R²=0.9783,支持实时个体化扩张方案制定[57]。

4.5 瘢痕力学量化、机械生物学与力-仿生平台

  瘢痕自身力学的量化与仿生平台是连接力学与计算的桥梁。体内外实验提出全层正常瘢痕的di-fork双力学隔室结构,结构力学模拟揭示瘢痕虽丧失部分组织成分,仍具应力适应性特征,可缓冲外部机械冲击、保护下层组织,维持皮肤机械屏障功能[58]。剪切波共振传播时间测量显示增生性瘢痕RRTM值低且方向依赖性小,萎缩性瘢痕RRTM更高(尤其横向),机械各向异性大于正常皮肤,瘢痕黑色素化rete ridge图案与皮肤内力主方向相关[59]。物理信息神经网络结合剪切波弹性成像反演瘢痕疙瘩空间弹性模量分布,通过超声兼容水凝胶将不规则自由边界转化为可处理界面,经有限元、体模与体内三级验证[60]。无标记多光子成像(双光子荧光+二次谐波)定义弹性蛋白-胶原形态相似度指标,瘢痕疙瘩组织相似度水平最高、邻近组织异质性最强,识别间质异型纤维特征的准确率超过98%[61]。智能手机拍摄生成瘢痕疙瘩3D模型,最长直径、厚度、体积的组内相关系数达0.998、0.978、0.993,与卡尺、注水法及超声高度一致,为量化随访提供工具[62]。

  机械生物学综述系统总结拉伸张力、剪切、压力与渗透压经整合素、细胞骨架与机械敏感通道触发机械转导,调控瘢痕形成、挛缩与瘢痕疙瘩进展,提出抑制机械感受与降低张力是预防治疗新方向[63];皮肤生物力学综述强调肌成纤维细胞对机械载荷的核心响应,建议联合压力治疗与张力卸载、开发收缩阻断生物材料,在愈合早期进行机械调控以避免瘢痕成熟[64]。跨组织建模亦提供机制类比:三维基于体/肺泡段的智能体与蒙特卡洛辐射输运耦合模型机理性地复现放射诱发肺纤维化,5分次放疗的功能亚单位存活更高、纤维化指数更低[65];VML伤口环境智能体模型WEABM作为医疗数字孪生核心,结合深度强化学习给出四设计原则(多模态介质控制、组织介质操纵促肌生成、工程化ECM功能性闭合、靶向胶原合成的抗纤维化药物)[66];边缘无界皮肤芯片模拟人体连续几何与体内力学平衡,对TGF-β1更敏感(ECM沉积、肌成纤维细胞活化、YAP信号与刚度升高),verteporfin抑制YAP后胶原沉积减少、组织免于硬化,形成与计算模型互补的力-仿生标定平台[67]。

4.6 瘢痕疙瘩与增生性瘢痕的数学模型

  专门针对瘢痕疙瘩的数学模型仍稀少。系统综述总结现有瘢痕疙瘩动力学模型主要涉及炎症与力学两方面,指出瘢痕疙瘩为人类特有疾病、无自然动物模型、实验进展有限,呼吁以体外-计算(in vitro/in silico)结合生成可检验假设,并综述由伤口愈合与实体瘤建模借鉴的新数学视角[68];正常与异常伤口愈合的局部及非局部模型在同一框架下系统比较,为瘢痕疙瘩蔓延的量化描述提供基础[69]。瘢痕疙瘩异质性综述指出至少两种表型(平展扩散型与隆起型),周边常为活性生长边缘而中心相对静止,周围“正常”皮肤亦表现部分瘢痕疙瘩特征,人源直接共培养的全层等价体外模型最有前景[70]。结合第4.3节的瘢痕边缘应力聚焦有限元分析[49]与第4.5节的PINN弹性成像[60],瘢痕疙瘩的“力学-数学”定量工具链正在成形。

4.7 瘢痕治疗仿真(激光、放疗、药物递送)

  增生性瘢痕激光光热有限元模型量化能量密度、脉冲宽度、光斑直径对温度升高与热损伤的影响:温升与剂量正相关,光斑增大时温升降低但热损伤加重,最优参数为能量密度7.5 J/cm²、脉宽4 ms、光斑7 mm,并经兔耳实验验证[71]。针对975 nm激光照射皮肤组织的完整热-流固耦合(ALE描述、辐射输运扩散近似+生物热方程+Ogden/Yeoh本构)模型,给出参数安全窗:调节激光参数可使组织内压维持在817 kPa以下同时产生治疗所需热梯度,从而最小化瘢痕风险[72]。个性化壳多糖/PLA 3D打印微针治疗胸部瘢痕疙瘩,将瘢痕压缩力学性能与有限元穿刺模拟结合,0.2配比提高打印精度与力学性能、载药提升6倍,微针可承受穿刺反作用力并达到有效穿刺深度[73]。双光束激光焊接皮肤伤口的跨尺度研究(拉曼、同步荧光、圆二色+分子动力学+COMSOL多物理场FEA)表明:40-60°C区间内,55-60°C窗口既能通过胶原中心区稳定氢键获得即时断裂强度,又能控制不可逆热损伤,模拟温度场与焊接后宏观形态吻合[74]。

4.8 系统生物学、网络分析与计算标志物筛选

  系统生物学路线把瘢痕视为信号网络问题。首个伤口愈合作为化学-生物-力学耦合的系统生物学计算框架,组合炎症信号、成纤维细胞与各向同性超弹性力学三场,证明三场均显著影响瘢痕形成、失衡导致疼痛性瘢痕,支持个体化伤口管理[75]。基于已验证的损伤启动伤口愈合系统生物学模型,模拟血小板、6种细胞与21种蛋白的时间进程,分析数千个场景并结合logistic回归与ROC定量评估,鉴定出IL-10、TIMP-1与纤连蛋白在伤后2周升高即可预测40天病理性瘢痕结局,准确率80%[76]。儿科伤口愈合与增生性瘢痕的多尺度系统建模综述围绕氧张力、TGF-β与机械拉伸三大机制组织框架,论证跨时空尺度整合的必要性[77]。

  “网络-机器学习-实验”三联范式成为当前最活跃的计算工作流:WGCNA与Lasso构建5基因瘢痕疙瘩诊断模型,并显示高低风险组在免疫、m6A与焦亡方面差异[78];增生性瘢痕WGCNA锁定黏着斑与TGF-β通路、枢纽蛋白ITGB1,虚拟筛选的crizotinib等药物经人瘢痕成纤维细胞与小鼠机械力模型验证[79];整合瘢痕疙瘩与代谢综合征数据的LASSO+机器学习签名(23基因,AUC 0.783/0.905)定位共享调控基因FERMT3,并在巨噬细胞与成纤维细胞中验证其代谢与增殖功能[80]。同类工作还包括ceRNA网络与随机森林诊断(ERRFI1)、机器学习特征选择诊断标志物(AMPH、TNFRSF9,AUC>0.85)等,共同构成瘢痕“计算生物标志物”谱。

4.9 临床预测模型与人工智能评估

  统计预测模型方面,703例2440个烧伤部位的分析显示77%出现病理性瘢痕,肥厚性诱导中位出现在再上皮化后23天、持续中位15个月,女性、年龄小、颈部/上肢烧伤、多次手术与网状皮片为独立危险因素,列线图区分度Dxy为0.30[81]。4238例甲状腺切除术多因素logistic模型识别瘢痕距胸骨切迹<1 cm(OR 4.345)、瘢痕疙瘩史(OR 2.789)、男性、BMI与胸锁乳突肌突出为术后增生性瘢痕风险因素[82];132例瘢痕疙瘩切除术的复发独立因素为感染、家族史、较大面积、未放疗与未局部激素,列线图AUC 0.889、准确率81.06%[83];301例手术+放疗数据的logistic、决策树、随机森林三模型比较中,决策树准确率最优而logistic的AUC最佳,KAAS评分、平均动脉压、并发症与炎症细胞比例为关键特征[84]。

  基因组与预测融合:WGCNA+LASSO+SVM-RFE筛选HGF、SDC4、ENPP2、RND3构建瘢痕疙瘩列线图,校准曲线与决策曲线均优[85];机器学习筛选免疫炎症签名基因COL1A1、A2M、TIMP1、COL1A2构建列线图,si-COL1A1转染抑制瘢痕成纤维细胞增殖并促凋亡,显示“预测-靶点”闭环[86]。临床-图像融合模型:以年龄、瘢痕高度及图像衍生指标(solidity、平均饱和度)经LASSO与logistic回归建立瘢痕核素治疗应答的个体化预测,联合模型AUC 0.970(训练)/0.908(验证),并发布在线计算器[87]。

  影像与深度学习:Google Cloud AutoML在3768张瘢痕图像上训练四分类筛查系统,平均精确率80.7%、AUC 0.846,总体准确率77%高于医生平均68.7%,kappa 0.69,可作为远程筛查工具[88];级联Vision Transformer基于激光散斑成像完成瘢痕疙瘩分割(Dice 0.895)、灌注定量与生长状态预测(准确率0.927)[89];Swin Transformer在3000张正常、2142张瘢痕与1431张其他疾病图像上取得瘢痕分型AUC 0.9696,并对VSS评分实现与专家一致性最高的疗效评估(MAE 0.5137)[90];迁移学习9种基础模型比较中VGG16瘢痕分类准确率0.985、AUC 0.996,DenseNet121在鉴别瘢痕疙瘩与外形相似恶性病变时最优[91]。空间频域成像+SVM在伤后24小时预测烧伤严重度准确率达92.5%-94.4%,可及早分类降低瘢痕与感染风险[92]。系统综述显示:烧伤创面机器学习评估领域30项研究中深度分类模型精度>83%[93];24项瘢痕AI研究的系统综述报告准确率63%-98.5%、AUC 0.342-1.0,约58%研究有外部验证且性能普遍下降(提示过拟合),大数据与多模态成像一般提升性能[94]。生活质量预测列线图确定吸烟、疼痛瘙痒与焦虑为瘢痕患者生活质量下降的危险因素,C-index 0.704[95]。

5 讨论

  检索结果呈现出清晰的方法谱系,自下而上可分为六个层级:①分子-细胞层动力学与网络模型(反应-扩散、钙波、uPA双稳态、PhysiCell框架);②组织层连续介质与形态弹性模型(胶原沉积、伤口收缩、烧伤挛缩);③跨尺度耦合方法学(ABM-FEM插值耦合、平滑粒子-连续体upsampling、双向黏附-力学积分点耦合);④手术与治疗仿真(缝合、皮瓣、成形术、穿刺孔、减张装置、压力面罩、激光光热与流固耦合、微针给药);⑤计算加速与反演层(高斯过程与贝叶斯神经网络的代理模型、物理信息神经网络弹性成像),使患者特异性实时仿真成为可能;⑥临床层(统计/机器学习预测、影像AI、数字孪生与力-仿生平台)。各层级之间的接口——本构参数标定、网格与边界条件假设、跨尺度映射规则——目前主要依靠实验数据桥接[33,36],这也是描述性综述反复出现的核心瓶颈。

  共性发现包括:伤口收缩与胶原定向是瘢痕形成的力学核心;张力是病理性瘢痕的可干预诱因,FMTB、减张缝合与压力治疗已有计算与实验双重证据[43,63,64];第4天左右的早期创面数据对最终结局具有预测力[28];表皮-真皮信号串扰决定瘢痕表型[16];参数敏感性集中于胶原平衡浓度、细胞凋亡率与信号衰减率[24,27]。主要局限与空白:多数模型缺乏前瞻性临床验证,缝合等辅助闭合技术对瘢痕影响的模型几乎空白[5],瘢痕疙瘩数学模型极少[68],AI临床模型外部验证不足[94],跨尺度模型尚无统一“瘢痕建模语言”。未来方向:患者特异性参数采集(非侵入张力/刚度测量[52,59,60])与代理模型结合,形成术前规划与数字孪生[45,66];力-仿生平台(器官芯片[67])与多组学网络[76-80]为模型提供标定与假设来源;力学校治疗与药物递送的联合仿真[71-74]可望给出参数安全窗的定量化临床指南。

  本综述的局限性:仅检索PubMed单库,按相关度采集前200条,未穷尽全部命中;以英文文献为主;采用描述性方法,未做meta分析与偏倚评估;题录分类由自动化分类与人工复核结合完成,可能存在系统误差;部分“预测模型”与“动物模型”边界判定存在灰区。

6 结论

  瘢痕相关数理与仿真建模已形成自“分子-细胞动力学”至“组织力学-手术/治疗仿真-临床预测”的完整方法链条,2020年后文献量加速增长,有限元/连续介质与机器学习为最活跃的两类方法。其价值在于将张力、胶原与信号网络等机制定量化,并已直接指导减张器械、激光参数与皮瓣设计。临床转化的关键在于参数个体化、前瞻性验证与标准化,计算代理加速与数字孪生是中长期方向。

参考文献

  1. Ogawa R. Mechanobiology of scarring Wound repair and regeneration : official publication of the Wound Healing Society [and] the European Tissue Repair Society. 2011;19 Suppl 1 :s2-9. PMID:21793962.
  2. Cao G. The Role of Biomechanical Forces in the Formation and Treatment of Pathological Scars Clinical, cosmetic and investigational dermatology. 2024;17 :2565-2571. PMID:39559183.
  3. Huang C. Fibroproliferative disorders and their mechanobiology Connective tissue research. 2012;53 3:187-96. PMID:22329637.
  4. Cerda E. Mechanics of scars Journal of biomechanics. 2005;38 8:1598-603. PMID:15958216.
  5. Jorgensen SN. Mathematical models of wound healing and closure: a comprehensive review Medical & biological engineering & computing. 2016;54 9:1297-316. PMID:26718553.
  6. Menon SN. Mathematical Modeling Can Advance Wound Healing Research Advances in wound care. 2021;10 6:328-344. PMID:32634070.
  7. Turley J. What good is maths in studies of wound healing? iScience. 2022;25 8:104778. PMID:35996582.
  8. Korkmaz HI. Scar formation from the perspective of complexity science: a new look at the biological system as a whole Journal of wound care. 2022;31 2:178-184. PMID:35148632.
  9. Dale PD. A mathematical model for collagen fibre formation during foetal and adult dermal wound healing Proceedings. Biological sciences. 1996;263 1370:653-60. PMID:8677263.
  10. Wearing HJ. Keratinocyte growth factor signalling: a mathematical model of dermal-epidermal interaction in epidermal wound healing Mathematical biosciences. 2000;165 1:41-62. PMID:10804259.
  11. Waugh HV. Modeling the effects of treating diabetic wounds with engineered skin substitutes Wound repair and regeneration : official publication of the Wound Healing Society [and] the European Tissue Repair Society. 2007;15 4:556-65. PMID:17650100.
  12. Rikard SM. Mathematical Model Predicts that Acceleration of Diabetic Wound Healing is Dependent on Spatial Distribution of VEGF-A mRNA (AZD8601) Cellular and molecular bioengineering. 2021;14 4:321-338. PMID:34290839.
  13. Haber SH. A Mathematical Model of Wound Healing Incorporating Strain-Induced MSC Differentiation Annals of biomedical engineering. 2026;54 1:102-116. PMID:41115986.
  14. Lazebnik T. PDE and agent based simulation approaches to Ischemic Dermal Wound Closure PloS one. 2026;21 5:e0340624. PMID:42090456.
  15. Andasari V. Computational model of wound healing: EGF secreted by fibroblasts promotes delayed re-epithelialization of epithelial keratinocytes Integrative biology : quantitative biosciences from nano to macro. 2018;10 10:605-634. PMID:30206629.
  16. Wang Y. A multiscale hybrid mathematical model of epidermal-dermal interactions during skin wound healing Experimental dermatology. 2019;28 4:493-502. PMID:30801791.
  17. Donati V. Calcium Signaling in the Photodamaged Skin: In Vivo Experiments and Mathematical Modeling Function (Oxford, England). 2021;3 1:zqab064. PMID:35330924.
  18. Stevens AC. A mathematical model of calcium signals around laser-induced epithelial wounds Molecular biology of the cell. 2023;34 6:ar49. PMID:36322412.
  19. Gilmore SJ. A mechanochemical model of striae distensae Mathematical biosciences. 2012;240 2:141-7. PMID:22796062.
  20. Garzón-Alvarado DA. A mathematical model of medial collateral ligament repair: migration, fibroblast proliferation and collagen formation Computer methods in biomechanics and biomedical engineering. 2012;15 6:571-83. PMID:21491258.
  21. Venkatraman L. The steady states and dynamics of urokinase-mediated plasmin activation Pacific Symposium on Biocomputing. Pacific Symposium on Biocomputing. 2010;:190-200. PMID:19908371.
  22. Hay Q. A mathematical model for wound healing in the reef-building coral Pocillopora damicornis Journal of theoretical biology. 2024;593 :111897. PMID:38971400.
  23. Yang L. A biomechanical model of wound contraction and scar formation Journal of theoretical biology. 2013;332 :228-48. PMID:23563057.
  24. Egberts G. Sensitivity and feasibility of a one-dimensional morphoelastic model for post-burn contraction Biomechanics and modeling in mechanobiology. 2021;20 6:2147-2167. PMID:34331622.
  25. Egberts G. Stability of a one-dimensional morphoelastic model for post-burn contraction Journal of mathematical biology. 2021;83 3:24. PMID:34355270.
  26. Egberts G. Stability of a two-dimensional biomorphoelastic model for post-burn contraction Journal of mathematical biology. 2023;86 4:59. PMID:36964257.
  27. Egberts G. Sensitivity of a two-dimensional biomorphoelastic model for post-burn contraction Biomechanics and modeling in mechanobiology. 2023;22 1:105-121. PMID:36229698.
  28. Peng Q. Agent-based modelling and parameter sensitivity analysis with a finite-element method for skin contraction Biomechanics and modeling in mechanobiology. 2020;19 6:2525-2551. PMID:32623543.
  29. Peng Q. Upscaling between an agent-based model (smoothed particle approach) and a continuum-based model for skin contractions Journal of mathematical biology. 2022;85 3:25. PMID:36056978.
  30. Guo Y. Multiscale mechanobiology: Coupling models of adhesion kinetics and nonlinear tissue mechanics Biophysical journal. 2022;121 4:525-539. PMID:35074393.
  31. Valero C. Nonlinear finite element simulations of injuries with free boundaries: application to surgical wounds International journal for numerical methods in biomedical engineering. 2014;30 6:616-33. PMID:24443355.
  32. De Jesus AM. A Combined In Vitro Imaging and Multi-Scale Modeling System for Studying the Role of Cell Matrix Interactions in Cutaneous Wound Healing PloS one. 2016;11 2:e0148254. PMID:26840835.
  33. Lee JJ. Spatial scaling in multiscale models: methods for coupling agent-based and finite-element models of wound healing Biomechanics and modeling in mechanobiology. 2019;18 5:1297-1309. PMID:30968216.
  34. Metzcar J. A Simple Framework for Agent-Based Modeling with Extracellular Matrix Bulletin of mathematical biology. 2025;87 3:43. PMID:39937344.
  35. Bischoff JE. Finite element modeling of human skin using an isotropic, nonlinear elastic constitutive model Journal of biomechanics. 2000;33 6:645-52. PMID:10807984.
  36. Alberini R. Second harmonic generation microscopy, biaxial mechanical tests and fiber dispersion models in human skin biomechanics Acta biomaterialia. 2024;185 :266-280. PMID:39048027.
  37. Lott-Crumpler DA. Optimal patterns for suturing wounds of complex shapes to foster healing Journal of biomechanics. 2001;34 1:51-8. PMID:11425080.
  38. Tepole AB. Computational modeling of skin: Using stress profiles as predictor for tissue necrosis in reconstructive surgery Computers & structures. 2014;143 :32-39. PMID:25225454.
  39. Buganza-Tepole A. Application of finite element modeling to optimize flap design with tissue expansion Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 2014;134 4:785-792. PMID:24945952.
  40. Spagnoli A. Simulation and optimization of reconstructive surgery procedures on human skin Journal of the mechanical behavior of biomedical materials. 2022;131 :105215. PMID:35472843.
  41. Papadakis M. Biomechanical explanation of W-plasty effectiveness using a finite element method approach Scientific reports. 2023;13 1:18109. PMID:37872283.
  42. Sha CM. Charting a finite element, mechanical atlas of dermatologic wound closure Computers in biology and medicine. 2025;196 Pt B:110839. PMID:40714411.
  43. Kazmer DO. Force Modulating Tissue Bridges for Reduction of Tension and Scar: Finite Element and Image Analysis of Preclinical Incisional and Nonincisional Models Aesthetic surgery journal. 2018;38 11:1250-1263. PMID:29635348.
  44. Wei Y. A finite element model of the 3D-printed transparent facemask for applying pressure therapy Clinical biomechanics (Bristol, Avon). 2021;87 :105414. PMID:34174674.
  45. Karkhaneh Yousefi AA. Patient-specific computational simulations of wound healing following midline laparotomy closure Biomechanics and modeling in mechanobiology. 2023;22 5:1589-1605. PMID:37024600.
  46. Kovář M. NUMERICAL EVALUATION OF SCAR AFTER BREAST RECONSTRUCTION WITH ABDOMINAL ADVANCEMENT FLAP Acta chirurgiae plasticae. 2016;58 1:12-17. PMID:27873527.
  47. Harbin Z. Computational mechanobiology model evaluating healing of postoperative cavities following breast-conserving surgery Computers in biology and medicine. 2023;165 :107342. PMID:37647782.
  48. Tuset L. A virtual simulation approach to assess the effect of trocar-site placement and scar characteristics on the abdominal wall biomechanics Scientific reports. 2024;14 1:3583. PMID:38351278.
  49. Ishii N. Finite Element Analysis of the Stress Changes Associated With the Growth of Acne Keloids Plastic and reconstructive surgery. Global open. 2024;12 12:e6365. PMID:39712380.
  50. Stowers C. Improving reconstructive surgery design using Gaussian process surrogates to capture material behavior uncertainty Journal of the mechanical behavior of biomedical materials. 2021;118 :104340. PMID:33756416.
  51. Egberts G. A Bayesian finite-element trained machine learning approach for predicting post-burn contraction Neural computing & applications. 2022;34 11:8635-8642. PMID:35125668.
  52. Nagle M. A Gaussian process approach for rapid evaluation of skin tension Acta biomaterialia. 2024;182 :54-66. PMID:38750916.
  53. Socci L. An axisymmetric computational model of skin expansion and growth Biomechanics and modeling in mechanobiology. 2007;6 3:177-88. PMID:16767451.
  54. Tepole AB. Growing skin: A computational model for skin expansion in reconstructive surgery Journal of the mechanics and physics of solids. 2011;59 10:2177-2190. PMID:22081726.
  55. Dommeti VK. Human Skin Expansion Using Circular Implants: A Finite Element Study Journal of long-term effects of medical implants. 2019;29 1:29-35. PMID:31679199.
  56. Moreno-Flores O. Numerical investigation of new rete ridge formation in a multi-layer model of skin subjected to tissue expansion Journal of biomechanics. 2024;176 :112346. PMID:39368318.
  57. Nagle M. A machine learning approach to predict in vivo skin growth Scientific reports. 2024;14 1:17456. PMID:39075147.
  58. Ghosh B. Structural mechanics modeling reveals stress-adaptive features of cutaneous scars Biomechanics and modeling in mechanobiology. 2021;20 1:371-377. PMID:32920729.
  59. Quatresooz P. Mechanobiology and force transduction in scars developed in darker skin types Skin research and technology : official journal of International Society for Bioengineering and the Skin (ISBS) [and] International Society for Digital Imaging of Skin (ISDIS) [and] International Society for Skin Imaging (ISSI). 2006;12 4:279-82. PMID:17026659.
  60. Yin Z. Learning mechanical inhomogeneity of keloid scars in vivo with shear wave elastography based on physics-informed neural networks Acta biomaterialia. 2025;208 :375-385. PMID:41176038.
  61. Wang C. Decoding elastin-collagen resemblance in keloid scar through label-free imaging and machine learning Journal of biomedical optics. 2026;31 3:036005. PMID:41835442.
  62. Jiang W. Use of a smartphone for imaging, modelling, and evaluation of keloids Burns : journal of the International Society for Burn Injuries. 2020;46 8:1896-1902. PMID:32646548.
  63. Téot L. Mechanobiology of Cutaneous Scarring . 2020. PMID:36351155.
  64. Hosseini M. Skin biomechanics: a potential therapeutic intervention target to reduce scarring Burns & trauma. 2022;10 :tkac036. PMID:36017082.
  65. Cogno N. Mechanistic model of radiotherapy-induced lung fibrosis using coupled 3D agent-based and Monte Carlo simulations Communications medicine. 2024;4 1:16. PMID:38336802.
  66. Cockrell C. The Wound Environment Agent-based Model (WEABM): a digital twin platform for characterization and complex therapeutic discovery for volumetric muscle loss bioRxiv : the preprint server for biology. 2024. PMID:38895374.
  67. Pappalardo A. A mechanomimetic model of skin fibrosis Lab on a chip. 2026;26 3:665-680. PMID:41521965.
  68. Eftimie R. Modelling Keloids Dynamics: A Brief Review and New Mathematical Perspectives Bulletin of mathematical biology. 2023;85 12:117. PMID:37855947.
  69. Adebayo OE. Mathematical investigation of normal and abnormal wound healing dynamics: local and non-local models Mathematical biosciences and engineering : MBE. 2023;20 9:17446-17498. PMID:37920062.
  70. Limandjaja GC. The Keloid Disorder: Heterogeneity, Histopathology, Mechanisms and Models Frontiers in cell and developmental biology. 2020;8 :360. PMID:32528951.
  71. Shen JC. Quantitative simulation of photothermal effect in laser therapy of hypertrophic scar Skin research and technology : official journal of International Society for Bioengineering and the Skin (ISBS) [and] International Society for Digital Imaging of Skin (ISDIS) [and] International Society for Skin Imaging (ISSI). 2023;29 3:e13305. PMID:36973985.
  72. Ochrymiuk T. A thermal-FSI framework for optimizing laser treatment of skin disorders Journal of biomechanics. 2025;193 :112997. PMID:41072091.
  73. Zhao Y. Integration of finite element simulations with 3D printing technology for personalized Chitin/PLA microneedle-based drug delivery systems in thoracic keloid treatment International journal of biological macromolecules. 2025;315 Pt 2:144487. PMID:40409657.
  74. Chen Y. Investigation of collagen reconstruction mechanism in skin wound through dual-beam laser welding: Insights from multi-spectroscopy, molecular dynamics simulation, and finite element multiphysics simulation Journal of photochemistry and photobiology. B, Biology. 2024;255 :112927. PMID:38701631.
  75. Buganza Tepole A. Computational modeling of chemo-bio-mechanical coupling: a systems-biology approach toward wound healing Computer methods in biomechanics and biomedical engineering. 2016;19 1:13-30. PMID:25421487.
  76. Nagaraja S. Computational analysis identifies putative prognostic biomarkers of pathological scarring in skin wounds Journal of translational medicine. 2018;16 1:32. PMID:29458433.
  77. Buganza Tepole A. Systems-based approaches toward wound healing Pediatric research. 2013;73 4 Pt 2:553-63. PMID:23314298.
  78. Xie J. Construction and validation of the diagnostic model of keloid based on weighted gene co-expression network analysis (WGCNA) and differential expression analysis Journal of plastic surgery and hand surgery. 2023;57 1-6:163-171. PMID:35001812.
  79. Zhang Y. Using network pharmacology to discover potential drugs for hypertrophic scars The British journal of dermatology. 2024;191 4:592-604. PMID:38820210.
  80. Lin Q. Integrative analysis identifies FERMT3 as a key regulator of metabolic reprogramming in keloid scarring and metabolic syndrome Functional & integrative genomics. 2025;25 1:188. PMID:40928556.
  81. Gangemi EN. Epidemiology and risk factors for pathologic scarring after burn wounds Archives of facial plastic surgery. 2008;10 2:93-102. PMID:18347236.
  82. Cho MY. Analysis of Risk Factors to Predict Occurrence and Prognosis of Postsurgical Hypertrophic Scar Development: A Review of 4238 Cases Yonsei medical journal. 2023;64 11:687-691. PMID:37880850.
  83. Hu X. Logistic regression analysis of risk factors influencing postoperative keloid scar recurrence American journal of translational research. 2024;16 9:4849-4857. PMID:39398575.
  84. Hao Y. Comparison of Predictive Models for Keloid Recurrence Based on Machine Learning Journal of cosmetic dermatology. 2025;24 2:e70008. PMID:39918034.
  85. Li Z. [Keloid nomogram prediction model based on weighted gene co-expression network analysis and machine learning] Sheng wu yi xue gong cheng xue za zhi = Journal of biomedical engineering = Shengwu yixue gongchengxue zazhi. 2023;40 4:725-735. PMID:37666763.
  86. Liu Y. Immune-related inflammatory gene in hypertrophic scar: prognostic and molecular mechanisms via integrated machine learning-WGCNA analysis Frontiers in immunology. 2025;16 :1645721. PMID:41229415.
  87. Su J. Personalized prediction model for scar response after radionuclide therapy: development and validation in a Chinese cohort Frontiers in medicine. 2025;12 :1655302. PMID:41158468.
  88. Ito H. Development of a Novel Scar Screening System with Machine Learning Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 2022;150 2:465e-472e. PMID:35687417.
  89. Li S. A Workflow for Computer-Aided Evaluation of Keloid Based on Laser Speckle Contrast Imaging and Deep Learning Journal of personalized medicine. 2022;12 6. PMID:35743764.
  90. Li Y. Deep Learning Models for Automatic Diagnosis and Efficacy Assessment of Scars: A Case Study Phenomics (Cham, Switzerland). 2026;6 3:296-306. PMID:42750840.
  91. Adebayo OE. Deep Learning Approaches for the Classification of Keloid Images in the Context of Malignant and Benign Skin Disorders Diagnostics (Basel, Switzerland). 2025;15 6. PMID:40150053.
  92. Rowland R. Burn wound classification model using spatial frequency-domain imaging and machine learning Journal of biomedical optics. 2019;24 5:1-9. PMID:31134769.
  93. Huang S. A systematic review of machine learning and automation in burn wound evaluation: A promising but developing frontier Burns : journal of the International Society for Burn Injuries. 2021;47 8:1691-1704. PMID:34419331.
  94. Gill HS. Systematic Review of Artificial Intelligence Applications in Scar Assessment and Management Plastic surgery (Oakville, Ont.). 2026;:22925503251407252. PMID:41522333.
  95. Xu S. A Nomogram Predicting Decreased Quality of Life in Patients with Keloids Clinical, cosmetic and investigational dermatology. 2026;19 :564610. PMID:41939262.

上传日期:2026年11月12日


关于本文:本文撰写与审核:吕开阳,执业医师,整形外科(主任医师),上海三甲医院。本站为个人科普站点,内容为医学教育材料,不构成对任何个体的诊疗建议;诊断与治疗方案须由具备资质的医师面诊确定,效果存在个体差异。本站不提供在线诊疗与首诊,就医请通过医院官方渠道挂号。沪ICP备2025119709号-1